Brooklynites Vote For Tax Spending That Makes Sense

July 21st, 2011

It’s market day in Cadman Plaza.  Nydia’s sign is inviting Brooklynites to vote with 20 pennies for the kinds of spending of our taxpayer dollars that makes most sense to them.

These guys on their lunch hour thought about it.  They’re telling Edith that what matters most is health care, “because what good is a job if your health’s no good.”

An interested visitor (and there were many today!) is looking at the literature Pat has given her after her vote.  There’s the graph from War Resisters’ League showing how the tax dollars are really spent.  She’s saying, “you can see today’s penny poll results on our blog, and here’s the web address (on the yellow quarter sheet)”

Sometimes we ask ourselves, is this time with people and Ms Gizmo (our penny poll machine) really accomplishing anything? Then we see how everyone’s concentrating hard, thinking about what matters, how many people are always willing to approach a table with PEACE written on its skirt.  We think it’s part of a picture we can’t see yet, but we’ll believe and keep going.

- Caroline Chinlund – words and pictures
- Edith Cresmer – chart
for the Granny Peace Brigade

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

THE 5TH ANNUAL CELEBRATION OF A LIVING DOCUMENT: THE U.S. CONSTITUTION ON THE 4TH OF JULY

July 9th, 2011

Strawberry Fields in Central Park was filled with patriots reading The Constitution, including Amendments, with application to ongoing injustices in our world.

Norman Siegel, civil liberties attorney and founder of the event, introduced musicians who spoke and whose rights are being infringed upon by the Quiet Zones recently instituted in Central Park. There were a large number of people from the Republic of Guinea West Africa bringing news of atrocities in their native country.  Norman Siegel has been addressing all of these problems.

The singing, reading, discussion all were very appropriate in celebrating that which is called Independence Day in these United States of America.

- Phyllis Cunningham
for the Granny Peace Brigade

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

How Do We Want Our Tax Dollars Spent?

July 6th, 2011

The scene: Just outside City Hall Park, NYC on Thursday, June 30 at lunchtime.

Two people are voting with 20 pennies each — as another, her vote in our gizmo tubes already, leaves reading the War Resister’s League info on where taxes are actually spent.  A third volunteer contemplates his vote.

This family from ‘way upstate’ approached.  “We love the Granny Peace Brigade..can we take your photo??”  Here they’re thinking about their priorities for tax spending as they agree to give us a photo of them.

Today people are sure that one category that really matters is jobs.


And here are the tallies for the day. As usual New Yorkers say we should spend most of our tax dollars on education, health care and jobs.

- Caroline, Edith and Eva-Lee
for the Granny Peace Brigade

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

DO NOT USE NYC TAX DOLLARS FOR JROTC!

June 6th, 2011

A voter calling to ask City Council to eliminate the approximately $2 million of taxpayer funds allocated to support the JROTC program in NYC high schools.

Hon. Robert Jackson
250 Broadway
Rm. 1747
New York, NY 10007

Re: elimination of funding for JROTC in the FY 2011 budget

Dear Councilmember Jackson:

The undersigned organizations write to ask that in its response to the Mayor’s Budget, the New York City Council, led by its Education Committee which you chair,  eliminate the approximately $2 million of taxpayer funds that will be used to support the JROTC program in the FY 2011 budget for the Department of Education.  At a time when the Mayor’s Budget calls for the laying off thousands of teachers, New York City’s resource-starved educational system can find far better uses for $2 million of taxpayer money than supporting a program whose basic goal is to promote militarism and foster sending New York City youth to participate in illegal and immoral occupations abroad.

As the attached chart indicates, the Federal government is paying slightly less than half the costs, apparently including all the fringe benefits, of this program.  The reason that the Federal government is paying the 41 JROTC teachers their fringe benefits is because they are not employees of the NYC DOE, but rather employees of the Federal government.  We believe that this sets a dangerous precedent of having individuals who do not possess the requisite qualifications to be a teacher in the DOE, nor who are members of the UFT, engage in teaching.

But more importantly, JROTC should be just about the lowest priority for the NYC DOE in the current budget.  You know better than most how under-resourced the City’s schools have been and continue to be, whether it is for teacher salaries, textbooks, or full time kindergarten – the list of desperate funding needs is long, and growing.

The overwhelming majority of NYC taxpayers have no idea that they are funding JROTC, and we submit that if they were informed of this fact, they would act to oppose such funding.  We understand that the Mayor has included funding for JROTC in his proposed FY 2011 education budget.  The budgetary process allows the Council to make changes in the Mayor’s budget, and the undersigned organizations urge the Council to eliminate this tax levy item in its response to the Mayor’s budget.  This unnecessary subsidy towards militarism should have no place in City’s FY 2011 budget, and we ask that you and the Council act promptly to recover these funds for far more important educational priorities.

We look forward to your, and the Council’s, leadership on this significant educational issue. This letter is being delivered to Speaker Christine Quinn and to all Members of the City Council Education Committee.

May we please hear from you.

Sincerely,
Barbara Harris

Barbara Harris, Chair Counter-Recruitment, Code Pink NYC Women for Peace
David Tykulsker, Vice-Chair, Brooklyn for Peace
Bob Keilbach, Secretary, Veterans for Peace, NYC Chapter 34
Alicia Godsberg, Executive Director, Peace Action New York State
Eva-Lee Baird, Granny Peace Brigade
Judith Le Blanc, National Field Director, Peace Action & Peace Action Fund
Henry Serrano, Senior Organizer, Voter Engagement Project Director,
Community Voices Heard
Rosemarie Pace, Director, Pax Christi Metro New York
Robert Jereski, Climate Action Group
Abby Scher, Chair, Brooklyn Society for Ethical Culture Social Action Committee
Harry Bubbins, Friends of Brook Park
Judy Lear, Convener, Gray Panthers NYC Network
Joan Wile, Founder/Director, Grandmothers Against the War
Paul Corell, Coordinating Committee, The Park Slope Greens
Jim Moschella, War Resisters League NYC
Peg Rapp, Coordinator, The Washington Heights Counter Recruitment Group
Jackie DiSalvo, Emerita Associate Professor, Baruch College CUNY
Alice Slater, Coordinator, Abolition2000, New York Metro
Jim McCabe, Metro New York Progressive Democrats of America
Lillian Rydell, President, Westside Peace Action
Molly Klopot, Chair, Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, NY Metro

cc:     Christine Quinn, Speaker
All members of City Council Education Committee

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

CITY COUNCIL VOTE DUE SOON Tell them – STOP FUNDING J-ROTC

June 1st, 2011

Through the J-ROTC program over $2,000,000 of our City Tax Levy is teaching children in 19 high schools how to be a soldier. Because few voters know about this particular misuse of their tax dollars we took to the streets with signs, flyers, cell phones and the very helpful THEY REPRESENT YOU booklet from the League of Women Voters.

Now more people know about that $2,000,000 and know how to contact their City Council member.*

We got lots of positive responses, a few negative, a smattering of phone calls and many more promises to call.

People were outraged to learn that a Department of the Army memorandum advises J-ROTC instructors to work closely with high school guidance counselors to sell the Army story.

See you in the streets.

-  Eva-Lee, Barbara H, Edith
for the Granny Peace Brigade

* To make a phone call to your NYC City Council member find the name and number at 212-788-7100 or http://council.nyc.gov/html/members/members.shtml.

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

Mothers Day Peace Stroll

May 10th, 2011

On May 8, 2011 the Granny Peace Brigade and CodePink went for the 5th annual Mothers Day Peace stroll through Central Park. (Click on the photos for larger images.)

We started off at Columbus Circle with songs by the Raging Grannies.
See and hear them in action.

Who is always one of the first to arrive at a Peace action?  It’s Bud Korotzer with Fran.  There were a lot of press people around eventually as we gathered at Columbus Circle, but we doubt that anybody got better photos than Bud.  He’s been getting the picture as long as we’ve been around.

Joan P and Jenny read Julia Ward Howe’s Mothers Day Proclamation to remind ourselves and our neighbors about the true meaning of this special day. The Proclamation is as pertinent now as it was when it was written 141 years ago.*

And we stepped off accompanied by the Rude Mechanical Orchestra.

Nancy K and Bev managed traffic.

Corinne invited Emily, her granddaughter from Connecticut.  Emily’s going to college in the fall, to study environmental science.

One of the things we loved about this mothers’ Day action was meeting the new people who joined us.

In peace always
The Granny Peace Brigade
Photos 1,3,4,5 – Phyllis Cunningham
Photos 2,6,7,8 – Caroline Chinlund

*Arise, then, women of this day!

Arise, all women who have hearts,

Whether our baptism be of water or of tears!

Say firmly:
“We will not have great questions decided by irrelevant agencies,
Our husbands will not come to us, reeking with carnage, for caresses and applause.
Our sons shall not be taken from us to unlearn
All that we have been able to teach them of charity, mercy and patience.
We, the women of one country, will be too tender of those of another country
To allow our sons to be trained to injure theirs.”

From the bosom of the devastated Earth a voice goes up with our own.
It says: “Disarm! Disarm! The sword of murder is not the balance of justice.”
Blood does not wipe out dishonor, nor violence indicate possession.
As men have often forsaken the plough and the anvil at the summons of war,
Let women now leave all that may be left of home for a great and earnest day of counsel.

Let them meet first, as women, to bewail and commemorate the dead.
Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means
Whereby the great human family can live in peace,
Each bearing after his own time the sacred impress, not of Caesar,
But of God.

In the name of womanhood and humanity, I earnestly ask
That a general congress of women without limit of nationality
May be appointed and held at someplace deemed most convenient
And at the earliest period consistent with its objects,
To promote the alliance of the different nationalities,
The amicable settlement of international questions,
The great and general interests of peace.

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

Upper West Siders Have Their Say

May 3rd, 2011

The lovely park outside the 1-2-3 Subway stop at 72nd and Broadway was the scene of our latest Penny Poll. (Click on photos for larger images.)

We asked neighborhood residents their opinion about how their tax dollars should be spent and each person deposited 20 pennies into some or all of the Gizmo’s eight tubes.

Education was the most important purpose by a long shot.  See the results in the chart below.

- Edith Cresmer
- Photos Phyllis Cunningham
for the Granny Peace Brigade

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

Adults and Students Disagree on Allocation of Tax Dollars

April 16th, 2011

This week when we set up Ms. Gizmo in Brooklyn near Borough Hall we attracted the attention of a new group of voters. Montessori students from all over the country were visiting with their teachers, and several groups stopped to vote in the penny poll and discuss tax dollar allocation. (Click on the photos for larger images.)

The results were slightly different from polls done at other Ms. Gizmo events in this location — with more pennies in the “Military” tube than usual. Boys in the classes were allocating more of their tax money to the military than does our usual crowd of adult passersby.


- Eva-Lee Baird
for the Granny Peace Brigade
Photos: Caroline Chinlund
Chart: Edith Cresmer

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

Demonstration for Peace, April 9th

April 13th, 2011

This is the Union Square scene and the people who heard  Vinie Burroughs’ speech. (Click on the photos for larger images.)

Our Philadelphia Granny Peace Brigade friends joined us.  Here they are with Corinne listening to the speakers in Union Square.

Resting away from the high volume of the speakers, I found two of many people who had come from Maine.  They got up at 1:00 AM to get on the bus and travel to NYC.

My companions, shown here with Lillian, were parents of a soldier who tried to get work when he returned from his first tour in Iraq.  He failed to find a job; the army refused to give him the Spanish language training he wanted so that he could be in the Border Patrol, which was the work he wanted to do.  His Mom said he felt he had no choice but to go back for a second, and now a third, tour.  “He has a wife and kids to support, “ she said.

Marching down Broadway was the moment I felt how many we were.  You could see us going on forever, in front and behind.  We were diverse; we were young and old; it felt like we have all the challenges and thrills of Tahrir Square ahead of us if we can stay committed to staying together and making a better nation.

There were more speeches in Foley Square.  The drone in the foreground was the work of a peace activist from Westchester.  Meeting people was energizing.  Cindy Sheehan,  Bill Perkins, religious leaders from the Muslim communities, and many others gave 90 second speeches.  Steve took his turn, urging people to stay aware they are making a difference by being out and being seen.  We were startled to find that there was virtually no news coverage of the demonstration and march.  New York 1 covered a labor rally in Times’ Square which was going on at the same time as the Peace demonstration.  CBS radio on the evening news mentioned that “thousands gathered in lower Manhattan” but there wasn’t one word in the New York Times.  It leaves me thinking we’ve got to be our own messengers.

- Caroline Chinlund
for the Granny Peace Brigade

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)

Brooklyn Votes Against War Spending

April 12th, 2011

Brooklynites began thinking about taxes when they saw our Penny Poll.  Ms. Gizmo attracted a crowd, including small children, and everyone thought carefully about where they wanted their tax dollars to go.

We provided twenty pennies to each voter and asked them to divide the pennies among eight tubes, representing  categories in the Federal Budget.  “Pretend you’re a Congressman, and these are twenty billion dollars,” we told them.  After they voted, we provided these active citizens with information [on the War Resisters League flyer] about where their taxes are really being spent.  Education is our game and pennies and tubes are our tools.

- Edith Cresmer
for the Granny Peace Brigade
Photos: Eva-Lee Baird

(Return to blog home)

(Return to GPB website)